Haru Glory - 40
Teh Knightmare - 40
Sophie is a Ninja - 37
Elphaba the Renthead - 37
Aphex_Ellie - Disqualified.
-----------------------------------------------
CA3SAR
Evrett
Theme: 20/20
Flow: 9/10
Appeal: 10/10
Creativity: 9/10
Comments: This is a great take on what was required. It definitely still feels like Evrett, but it's got a different style to it. My only issue is that it seems that each item was chosen for it's similarity to an item on the original (a headband, a glove), but that's a very minor problem. The use of the shell collection bothers me like it did on the original. It doesn't really fit the character for me.
--------------------------------------------------------
Sophie is a Ninja
Kova
Theme: 17/20
Flow: 7/10
Appeal: 6/10
Creativity: 7/10
Comments: I like that you went so far as to change Kova's race (from Half-Orc), whether on purpose or not. It's not exactly what I wanted, but it definitely shows your style while keeping most of the character in tact. I'm slight bothered by the armor. It's a hodge-podge of colors and textures while the original was incredibly detailed and kept to one style.
--------------------------------------------------------
Elphaba the Renthead
Melkor
Theme: 17/20
Flow: 7/10
Appeal: 7/10
Creativity: 6/10
Comments: I'm slightly disappointed to see a couple of major items repeated (the helmet and the shoulder armor), but I think he varies enough to give it a different feel without losing the character. I would have liked to see at least some change in the face though. You were given a lot of freedom and you kept it safe.
--------------------------------------------------------
Haru Glory
Tor
Theme: 17/20
Flow: 8/10
Appeal: 8/10
Creativity: 7/10
Comments: Once again, I would have liked a bit more change in face, but this is well done. Would have liked to see the leggings change though.
--------------------------------------------------------
Teh Knightmare
Orniel
Theme: 15/20
Flow: 7/10
Appeal: 8/10
Creativity: 10/10
Comments: This is an awkward entry to judge. I love that you went so far out. But I'm not completely sold on it being Orniel. I like the use of the cape (it gives the same feel as the original's dress), but beyond that it's hard to draw deeper connections.
